Attachment Parenting or CIO?


Before becoming a parent I researched several different parenting styles. I wanted obviously to provide my child with a nurturing loving atmosphere. The parenting style that seemed right at the time for us was attachment style parenting. I chose that method because I wanted to have this unbreakable bond with my child. I wanted my child to know that I was there for whatever he needed. This worked decently for a while. But I soon realized that being a child care provider meant I could not spend all my time attached to my own child because I would be neglecting the needs of the other children in my care. My methods soon went out the window and I just handled each situation as they came along and there was no method to my madness…

Those of you that successfully pull off attachment style parenting with multiple kids, I applaud you. I really do. So while I’ve never thought CIO (Cry it Out) was a bad thing, I just thought that I would use that as a last resort. I was certain I could come up with other ways to help my child soothe himself. What I have recently learned with an almost two-year-old over the course of his short little life, I have not taught him self-soothing skills. I have really done him a dis-service.

The times when we would let him “cry it out”, 15 minutes later we are changing vomit filled bedding. The work to strip the sheets and bedding from the crib, get them in the washer, running the washer and dryer, bathing the child every night til he learned how to self-sooth seemed downright silly as an every night occurrence. Taking the time to rock him til he was sleepy didn’t seem like coddling all that much anymore. He’s my baby, babies are meant to be cuddled. Now keep in mind since about 9 months or so, I’ve been able to rock the child til he was “sleepy” then lay him in his crib and he’d babble himself to sleep.  This worked most nights.

Lately though because I’ve cut out the nap time rocking, due to having an infant in my care and well due to the fact I never rocked CB and I only rocked big J enough to get him sleepy and put him in his pack n play when he was an infant and that was just a 2 week process til he got the hint, that this was nap time. I’d successfully lay the two other toddlers in their pack n plays and they would be out within minutes. But I still took the time to rock my own son til he was sleepy during nap times….thus causing him a dis-service being unable to put himself to sleep at almost 2 years of age.

So now I am going thru the daunting task of teaching my son to self-soothe and to once and for all put himself to sleep when I lay him in his crib. This he should have learned a long time ago. But he was my baby, and my first and I enjoyed watching him drift off into sleepy land.

So now I am completely for this CIO method. I no longer want to coddle. I want to soothe when he needs it, but I have learned my lesson the hard way. If he was in daycare he would be doing this already…I would not be writing this post. But since I am the one with him day in and day out, I have babied him…mainly because I just didn’t want him to grow up. Now I need him to be a little more self-sufficient.

So now I must teach this, and the method is talking him thru the screaming and tantrum throwing calmly, and of course letting him cry it out. The letting him cry it out part is hard on me. I listen to the screaming and all I want to do is just to do something about it…..not realizing the screaming is the process. Its the process he has to go thru to learn how to cope. If I disrupt the process I’m teaching him that I will come in and fix his world for him instead of him fixing it for himself. I’m teaching him that if he screams long enough, I’ll just come in and give in and rock him. So I have to hold myself back and let him have at it. Let him scream, let him throw his tantrum. I’ve heard the tantrums get shorter until he learns, but we’ve been so afraid of the vomiting when he gets worked up, that we’ve never let him fully complete a cry out session….so here is for hoping! Wish me luck!

This is going to be soo hard on me!

About Heather Jones

I'm just a wife and mom of two boys trying to find her place in this world. I enjoy walks around the lake, bible journaling, and RV camping with my family.

Heartfully Heather


This blog is a personal blog written and edited by me, Heather Jones. For questions about this blog, please contact me via the “Contact Me” link on the top menu bar or click here. This blog accepts forms of cash advertising, sponsorship, paid insertions or other forms of compensation.

Disclosure Policy For Reviews / Guest/Sponsored Posts: 

The compensation received may influence the advertising content, topics or posts made in this blog. That content, advertising space or post may not always be identified as paid or sponsored content.

The owner of this blog is compensated to provide opinions on products, services, websites and various other topics. Even though the owner of this blog receives compensation for posts or advertisements, I (we) always give our honest opinions, findings, beliefs, or experiences on those topics or products. The views and opinions expressed on this blog are purely the bloggers’ own. Any product claim, statistic, quote or other representation about a product or service should be verified with the manufacturer, provider or party in question.

To see more of my disclosure policy please click here.

Heather Jones

I'm just a wife and mom of two boys trying to find her place in this world. I enjoy walks around the lake, bible journaling, and RV camping with my family.

6 thoughts on “Attachment Parenting or CIO?

  1. Okay, we did AP and now my daughter is 3 and cannot sleep in her own bed. I am going crazy with lack of sleep. She is happy now, rarely cries, and is a good girl but just can’t sleep by herself. I realize now, we are going to have to let her cry. This is hard!

  2. I have so been there! I have 4 kids… it has been an ongoing learning process. Each time it’s been something tweaked a little to make it work. I would say that I am a “loosely” attachment parenting mom… some things work well… to a point. For me, anyway 🙂 It is rough. Best of luck to you!

  3. I so know what you are going through! My second is also a boy, and since I believe he will be our last, I’ve kind of babied him a little more. He is 20 months old, and I still rock him to sleep. Not till he is sleepy, mind you, I mean all the way asleep. He has stopped letting me rock him at night – I think he is trying to tell me something… And so now he gets put into bed awake at night. The first few days were tough. And yep, I went to him after a few minutes, which made him cry more the next day. You have to stick to your guns. Sigh. And try not to cry yourself, which I found myself doing that first week. But now he is a pro… I just need to do it for his nap time now…..
    Good luck!

  4. It is hard! I had to do it with my oldest when rocking her to sleep became out of the question. I never even meant to be a rocker, it just happened! I used the Supernanny method- sit where they can see you but your aren’t looking at them, each night sit a little farther away until eventually you are out of eyesight. Takes about 5 nights (or it did for us!)

What are your thoughts?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.